You are the sweetest guy I've ever seen

The story:

I knew Elton John was gay, so it made sense to me that he would sing a love song about another guy. This past December, I went to a karaoke bar with my cousins and friends. As someone was singing this song, I was looking at the screen and caught my mistake. Thankfully I was the only one in the group who had heard the song, so it wasn't too embarassing